Abstract
Rangelands in South Africa have long contested histories embedded in their characterisation as ‘frontiers’ during the settler-colonial era, ‘homelands’ during the apartheid era and ‘communal areas’ in the post-1994 democratic era. Common-pool resources found in rangelands have similarly been subject to contested governance regimes, from enclosure and privatisation to centralised state management and decentralised community-based governance. These changing regimes introduced overlapping institutions, with the governance of communal rangelands now shared by government, traditional leaders, non-governmental organisations and community-based organisations. This has produced governance ambiguity in practice, with uncertainty surrounding the governance powers and legitimacy of local institutions. Governance ambiguity enables resource users to act in ways unaligned with governance rules. More powerful actors can increase resource access whilst others may become marginalised, creating inequities in resource governance.This study empirically examined the implications of these governance dilemmas for the implementation of community-based governance interventions in two communities in the Matatiele area of the Eastern Cape, South Africa. Following a mixed-methods approach, the study assessed the barriers to and opportunities for more ecologically sustainable and socially equitable outcomes within these interventions. The analysis deployed a conceptual framework integrating approaches from critical institutionalist and environmental peacebuilding disciplines to unpack the complex historical, ecological and social dynamics affecting resource governance.
Institutional barriers include an overly rigid interpretation of resource boundaries and users, failing to recognise the fluid, relational and seasonal management of resources in practice. Coupled with this is the ecological impact of invasive alien plant species which have dramatically reconfigured resource boundaries and land-use. Without sufficient flexibility and ability to control alien species, local institutions will struggle to enforce governance arrangements no longer matching the ecological realities of everyday resource access. Socially, challenges were identified in the inability of market-based interventions to account for power asymmetries and the disproportionate ability of more powerful actors to gain benefits, including larger cattle owners, business owners and small-scale commercial producers. The inability to navigate these social dynamics risks further embedding inequitable access and the power asymmetries identified as root causes of conflict in these communities.
To address these dynamics, governance interventions will need to adopt a more fluid and holistic approach to rangeland governance focussing on a broader range of services beyond grazing forage and market access. These include access to water, timber, thatching grass, traditional medicine and human security to ensure more equitable outcomes. A more strategic focus is needed to address invasive alien plant encroachment in areas where access to these resources is impeded, and safety concerns for residents have been raised. Institutionally, interventions should incorporate nested enterprises to better align the management of different resources and represent the diffuse groups of resource users. Deliberately incorporating more informal institutions and marginalised groups including elderly, disabled and female residents also needs to be a cornerstone of nested enterprises. Doing so will not only ensure more joined-up management of resources but will also bolster more democratic institutions able to counterbalance power asymmetries which have impeded the equitability of governance interventions.
| Date of Award | Aug 2025 |
|---|---|
| Original language | English |
| Awarding Institution |
|
| Sponsors | Global Challenges Research Fund |
| Supervisor | James Bennett (Supervisor), Elly Harrowell (Supervisor) & Lovemore Gwiriri (Supervisor) |
Keywords
- Rangeland governance
- Communal rangelands
- Common-pool resources
- Governance ambiguity
- Community-based governance
- Critical institutionalism
- Environmental peacebuilding
- Power asymmetries
- Invasive alien species
- Eastern Cape (South Africa)
Cite this
- Standard