Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

The Role of the Ornamental Horticulture Sector in Plant Invasions Across Southern Africa

  • Diana Rodríguez-Cala

Student thesis: Doctoral Thesis › Doctor of Philosophy

Abstract

Biological invasions are increasingly gaining attention due to their rising impacts, often combined with other drivers of biodiversity change. Historically, ornamental horticulture worldwide has significantly influenced plant invasions, and Southern Africa is no exception. A significant proportion of introduced ornamental plants have become invasive across the sub-region. However, documentation and research of plant invasions, including inventories and their management, are scattered and often focused on a single country. South Africa stands out as a hotspot in research and management of plant invasions. Studies in South Africa and elsewhere in the sub-region indicate that perceptions of invasive plants are complex, dynamic, and nuanced. In addition, studies show that stakeholder conflicts can jeopardise invasion management success, often reflecting societal injustices. Hence, it is essential to unpack the human dimensions of biological invasions in the sub-region.

This thesis examines the role of the ornamental horticulture sector in plant invasions in Southern Africa. It focuses on the human dimensions shaping this interplay, given the significant number of species introduced through the ornamental trade and the conflicts in managing invasive ornamental plants reported in South Africa. To achieve this, I have: i) identified which invasive plants are currently used within the ornamental horticulture sector; ii) identified the supply chain’s structure and dynamics and the practices within the ornamental horticulture sector; iii) assessed the perceptions of alien and invasive ornamental plants from the stakeholders involved; and iv) provided recommendations for an integrated governance approach to ornamental-related biological invasions.

The research integrated quantitative and qualitative methods using a patchwork ethnographic approach with critical realism as the philosophical underpinning. Methods included plant surveys with descriptive statistics, semi-structured interviews, questionnaires, participant observations, focus groups, workshops, and thematic analysis. Participants included environmental specialists, ornamental industry staff, and gardeners (or end users). Data were generated and analysed from 191 participants from Botswana, Namibia, Zimbabwe, South Africa, Zambia, the Democratic Republic of Congo, and Eswatini, with visits to 66 sites across Botswana, Namibia, and Zimbabwe.

Key findings include:

At least 22% (289) of the 1,211 plants on sale in 11 nurseries of Botswana, Namibia, and Zimbabwe have established alien populations in the sub-region, with 82 of these being invasive in at least one continental country of Southern Africa. Given the popularity and establishment of many of these plants in the global market, this high invasion debt might create conflicts if management efforts are taken.

South Africa (and Zimbabwe to a lesser extent) plays a hegemonic role within the sub-regional ornamental sector, having the colonial legacy of the British and Dutch ornamental industry and being the leading supplier and model to follow in the sub-region. The sector increasingly provides ‘formal’ and ‘informal’ livelihoods in urban areas, especially for women. It reflects a deep cultural mixing that typifies postcolonial African societies. Alien plants and foreign styles usually symbolise higher social status. Still, modern trends toward more geographically contextualised gardening practices and native plants are also in fashion.

There are commonalities and differences in perceptions and understandings amongst participants that might affect the management of ornamental-related invasions. Although people’s perceptions of invasive species and particular ornamental plants vary due to different interests, socio-economic, cultural contexts, and personal experiences with the plants, the overall understanding of the key concepts of biological invasion does not differ substantially across environmental specialists, ornamental industry staff, and ornamental gardeners or end users in Southern Africa.

Practical recommendations are provided to facilitate conflict management and decision-making in managing ornamental-related invasions, mainly in Botswana, Namibia, and Zimbabwe. Recommendations emphasise the need to consider power imbalances in the sub-region at individual, group, societal, and regional levels.

This thesis conveys that complex processes, termed “products of history,” influence the likelihood of plants becoming invasive through interactions with the ornamental sector and related practices. For invasion management to be feasible and sustainable, environmental specialists must practice environmental management that does not neglect social and geopolitical realities, counteracts power concentration and marginalisation, and incorporates sensitivity, care, and justice.
Date of AwardApr 2025
Original languageEnglish
Awarding Institution
  • Coventry University
SupervisorJana Fried (Supervisor), Katharina Dehnen-Schmutz (Supervisor) & John Wilson (Supervisor)

Keywords

  • Biological Invasions
  • Ornamental Horticulture
  • Invasive Alien Plants
  • Human Dimensions
  • Invasion Management
  • Stakeholder Perceptions
  • Environmental Governance
  • Invasion Debt
  • Critical Realism
  • Southern Africa

Cite this

'