Abstract
Matrix management has gained increased popularity as a tool of organisational structure. In a traditional hierarchical organisation, employees typically have one direct manager to whom they report and receive instructions. In a matrix management structure, employees have multiple reporting relationships. This can bring complexities and challenges, especially in a modern organisation operating globally across borders, time zones and cultures. However, implementing a matrix structure can also offer many benefits, such as increased collaboration and flexibility, which are both critical in such multinational organisations. To ensure the success of a matrix organisation, it is vital to identify the essential factors of success that can help overcome the challenges.The thesis answers two key research questions. Firstly, whether matrix management works effectively in organisations spanning cultural borders and, secondly, whether it suits higher education institutes in the broader South East Asia region. These inquiries are enriched by insights drawn from Coventry University's unique experience, fostering a sense of engagement and connection with the research.
In examining the existing literature on matrix management, the history and different types of matrix management models, drawing on examples of how commercial entities implement matrix structures, were explored. From this review, it was identified that Coventry University practises the two-hat matrix model. The 'two-hat matrix model' in a matrix organisation refers to a management structure where employees have dual reporting relationships. Essentially, they wear 'Two Hats' — one for each of their roles. In this model, an employee reports to two different managers. One is the functional manager, who oversees the employee's work within a specific function or department; the other is the product or project manager, who supervises the employee’s work on specific projects or products. However, the Two Hats Matrix model could be described as static, neglecting key influences in the organisational environment that can impact the successful operation of the matrix organisation.
In addressing this, eight main themes or propositions that may impact a matrix organisation's success were identified, four from the literature review and four from a subsequent series of in-depth interviews with key stakeholders working in Coventry University’s matrix structure. These are communication, power, responsibility, cross cultural impact, trust, collaboration, alignment in decision making, and organisation structure design.
Subsequent validation of these themes through follow-up interviews with senior leaders at Coventry University forms the basis for discussing their implications within a university setting. The analysis outlines the advantages and challenges of matrix structures, offering recommendations for effective implementation.
Based on the research findings and analysis, a matrix organisation implementation paper tailored for Coventry University is presented. This implementation paper aims to enhance productivity and efficiency, thereby making a positive commercial impact on the organisation. Furthermore, identifying four new themes from the research interview process significantly contributes to advancing knowledge relating to matrix management within academic circles, underlining the importance of the study.
A key contribution of the research is a new dynamic and sustainable matrix management model named the 'Two Hats Plus Matrix Model' that can potentially bring value to all organisations. It is proposed that using this new matrix model to implement a matrix structure can contribute to the organisation’s productivity and effectiveness, but only if due consideration is given to the key influencing role of the eight themes identified from the research.
| Date of Award | Sept 2024 |
|---|---|
| Original language | English |
| Awarding Institution |
|
| Supervisor | Nigel Berkeley (Supervisor) |
Keywords
- Matrix management
- Two-Hat Matrix Model
- Dual reporting relationships
- Cross-cultural impact
- Collaboration
- Communication
- Organisational structure design
- Responsibility and power dynamics
- Two Hats Plus Matrix Model
- Higher education context
Cite this
- Standard