Abstract
Forests and tree-based landscapes are particularly relevant in Africa, where most of the population is rural and dependent on ecosystem services for everyday life and livelihoods. Despite this importance, the rate at which forests are lost in Africa is higher than on any other continent. It is therefore urgent to reverse this trend. Tree planting is one approach that Africa’s leaders are embracing to reduce the loss and degradation of forests and to restore forested landscapes. Tree planting has existed for centuries, although it has recently been intensified and scaled up through multinational environmental agreements. In conformance with these multinational environmental agreements, several African countries have made governance reforms and adopted tools to ensure the success of tree planting schemes. However, to date, the success of these efforts is insufficient because of the lack of comprehensive and practical governance tools and mechanisms, limited alignment with good governance practices, legitimacy issues, and macro-environment factors.This thesis employed a mixed-methods approach using qualitative and semi-quantitative tools to assess the governance of tree planting schemes across four African countries, with a deeper focus on Ethiopia. A case study method was used to explore and describe governance processes at national and local levels. Data were collected through interviews, focus group discussions with community representatives, document reviews, and remote sensing. The analysis employed qualitative and semi-quantitative methods, including grounded theory and content analysis, to identify patterns and themes. Likert scales and NVIVO software were used to assess the governance, legitimacy, and socio-economic outputs of tree planting schemes. The PESTEL framework was applied to examine macro-environment factors across the four African countries.
The thesis consists of four interrelated studies. Chapter 2 systematically reviewed existing literature on the governance of tree planting schemes. Using this review, a governance framework was proposed to guide the design and evaluation of these schemes. Chapter 3 assessed the socioeconomic and environmental performance of sixteen tree planting schemes. The findings showed that most schemes did not adhere to implementation guidelines and rarely delivered their intended targets; consequently, they failed to secure legitimacy among local communities. Chapter 4 examined local communities’ perceptions of the governance process. The findings revealed a lack of genuine participation, institutionalisation, and capacity building, thereby weakening community commitment and undermining the sustainability of scheme outcomes.
Chapter 5 analysed the macro-environment factors influencing tree planting schemes using the PESTEL framework. The analysis identified two additional influential factors, namely historical and organisational dimensions, and demonstrated that while some aspects receive greater attention than others, all factors are interconnected and jointly influence scheme outcomes.
These studies make significant contributions to the science, practice, and policy of African tree planting schemes by providing a novel governance framework, an integrated assessment methodology, a community governance perspective, and an enhanced PESTEL framework. The thesis concludes that tree planting schemes need to adopt comprehensive governance approaches, align more closely with good governance principles and community perspectives, and address macro-environment influences in order to follow a sustainable pathway towards long-term success.
| Date of Award | Jan 2025 |
|---|---|
| Original language | English |
| Awarding Institution |
|
| Sponsors | The Rufford Foundation & Coventry University |
| Supervisor | Katharina Dehnen-Schmutz (Supervisor), John Wilson (Supervisor) & Adrian Evans (Supervisor) |
Keywords
- Tree Planting Governance
- Forest Landscape Restoration
- Environmental Governance
- Community Participation
- Legitimacy of Environmental Interventions
- Socio-ecological Sustainability
- Forest Conservation in Africa
- PESTEL Analysis
- Mixed-Methods Research
- Ethiopia and African Forestry Policy
Cite this
- Standard