The combined effect of ultrasound and ozone on bacteria in water

A.M. Al-hashimi, Timothy J. Mason, Eaodoin Joyce

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

14 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Aim of the study: To assess the synergetic effect of combined ultrasound and ozone treatment on the biological disinfection of water on a large-scale application using viable plate counts and flow cytometry. Methods and results: Escherichia coli B bacteria in saline suspension was treated using a commercially available combined ultrasound and ozone system (USS, Ultrasonic Systems Gmbh, Germany) for 16 minutes. Two analytical methods were used to assess the results in terms of live and dead cells in the bulk liquid: standard viable plate counting recorded in terms of Colony Forming Units (CFU) per ml and flow cytometry (FCM). In the latter case 1 ml bacterial suspension was stained simultaneously with the fluorescent stains SYTO9 and Propidium Iodide (PI). Transmission electron microscopy was used to generate images identifying the biological effects of different treatments using ultrasound and ozone on bacterial cell walls. Results demonstrated that treatment with ozone alone (0.5 mg/l) resulted in a significant reduction (93%) in the number of live cells after 16 minutes treatment whereas ultrasound alone showed only a small reduction (24%). However a combination of ozone and ultrasound showed a synergistic effect and enhanced the inactivation to 99%. Conclusion: A combined ultrasound and ozone treatment of bacterial suspensions using a commercial system (USS, Ultrasonic Systems Gmbh) affords a promising method for water disinfection that is better than treatment using either method alone. Standard viable plate count analysis is normally used to assess the effectiveness of disinfection treatments; however flow cytometry proved to be a more sensitive method to determine the actual effects in terms of not only live and dead cells but also damaged cells. This type of analysis (cell damage) is difficult if not impossible to achieve using traditional plate counting methodology.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)11697–11702
JournalEnvironmental Science and Technology
Volume49
Issue number19
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Fingerprint

Ozone
Bacteria
Ultrasonics
ozone
bacterium
Water
flow cytometry
disinfection
Flow cytometry
Disinfection
water
Suspensions
iodide
Cells
ultrasound
effect
transmission electron microscopy
analytical method
Propidium
Escherichia coli

Bibliographical note

Full text is available free with registration on the publisher's website.

Keywords

  • ultrasound
  • ozone
  • biological disinfection
  • water treatment
  • water disinfection

Cite this

The combined effect of ultrasound and ozone on bacteria in water. / Al-hashimi, A.M.; Mason, Timothy J.; Joyce, Eaodoin.

In: Environmental Science and Technology, Vol. 49, No. 19, 2015, p. 11697–11702.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Al-hashimi, A.M. ; Mason, Timothy J. ; Joyce, Eaodoin. / The combined effect of ultrasound and ozone on bacteria in water. In: Environmental Science and Technology. 2015 ; Vol. 49, No. 19. pp. 11697–11702.
@article{39f702cb2e164bd2b78039e3895a4969,
title = "The combined effect of ultrasound and ozone on bacteria in water",
abstract = "Aim of the study: To assess the synergetic effect of combined ultrasound and ozone treatment on the biological disinfection of water on a large-scale application using viable plate counts and flow cytometry. Methods and results: Escherichia coli B bacteria in saline suspension was treated using a commercially available combined ultrasound and ozone system (USS, Ultrasonic Systems Gmbh, Germany) for 16 minutes. Two analytical methods were used to assess the results in terms of live and dead cells in the bulk liquid: standard viable plate counting recorded in terms of Colony Forming Units (CFU) per ml and flow cytometry (FCM). In the latter case 1 ml bacterial suspension was stained simultaneously with the fluorescent stains SYTO9 and Propidium Iodide (PI). Transmission electron microscopy was used to generate images identifying the biological effects of different treatments using ultrasound and ozone on bacterial cell walls. Results demonstrated that treatment with ozone alone (0.5 mg/l) resulted in a significant reduction (93{\%}) in the number of live cells after 16 minutes treatment whereas ultrasound alone showed only a small reduction (24{\%}). However a combination of ozone and ultrasound showed a synergistic effect and enhanced the inactivation to 99{\%}. Conclusion: A combined ultrasound and ozone treatment of bacterial suspensions using a commercial system (USS, Ultrasonic Systems Gmbh) affords a promising method for water disinfection that is better than treatment using either method alone. Standard viable plate count analysis is normally used to assess the effectiveness of disinfection treatments; however flow cytometry proved to be a more sensitive method to determine the actual effects in terms of not only live and dead cells but also damaged cells. This type of analysis (cell damage) is difficult if not impossible to achieve using traditional plate counting methodology.",
keywords = "ultrasound, ozone, biological disinfection, water treatment, water disinfection",
author = "A.M. Al-hashimi and Mason, {Timothy J.} and Eaodoin Joyce",
note = "Full text is available free with registration on the publisher's website.",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.1021/es5045437",
language = "English",
volume = "49",
pages = "11697–11702",
journal = "Environmental Science & Technology",
issn = "0013-936X",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
number = "19",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The combined effect of ultrasound and ozone on bacteria in water

AU - Al-hashimi, A.M.

AU - Mason, Timothy J.

AU - Joyce, Eaodoin

N1 - Full text is available free with registration on the publisher's website.

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Aim of the study: To assess the synergetic effect of combined ultrasound and ozone treatment on the biological disinfection of water on a large-scale application using viable plate counts and flow cytometry. Methods and results: Escherichia coli B bacteria in saline suspension was treated using a commercially available combined ultrasound and ozone system (USS, Ultrasonic Systems Gmbh, Germany) for 16 minutes. Two analytical methods were used to assess the results in terms of live and dead cells in the bulk liquid: standard viable plate counting recorded in terms of Colony Forming Units (CFU) per ml and flow cytometry (FCM). In the latter case 1 ml bacterial suspension was stained simultaneously with the fluorescent stains SYTO9 and Propidium Iodide (PI). Transmission electron microscopy was used to generate images identifying the biological effects of different treatments using ultrasound and ozone on bacterial cell walls. Results demonstrated that treatment with ozone alone (0.5 mg/l) resulted in a significant reduction (93%) in the number of live cells after 16 minutes treatment whereas ultrasound alone showed only a small reduction (24%). However a combination of ozone and ultrasound showed a synergistic effect and enhanced the inactivation to 99%. Conclusion: A combined ultrasound and ozone treatment of bacterial suspensions using a commercial system (USS, Ultrasonic Systems Gmbh) affords a promising method for water disinfection that is better than treatment using either method alone. Standard viable plate count analysis is normally used to assess the effectiveness of disinfection treatments; however flow cytometry proved to be a more sensitive method to determine the actual effects in terms of not only live and dead cells but also damaged cells. This type of analysis (cell damage) is difficult if not impossible to achieve using traditional plate counting methodology.

AB - Aim of the study: To assess the synergetic effect of combined ultrasound and ozone treatment on the biological disinfection of water on a large-scale application using viable plate counts and flow cytometry. Methods and results: Escherichia coli B bacteria in saline suspension was treated using a commercially available combined ultrasound and ozone system (USS, Ultrasonic Systems Gmbh, Germany) for 16 minutes. Two analytical methods were used to assess the results in terms of live and dead cells in the bulk liquid: standard viable plate counting recorded in terms of Colony Forming Units (CFU) per ml and flow cytometry (FCM). In the latter case 1 ml bacterial suspension was stained simultaneously with the fluorescent stains SYTO9 and Propidium Iodide (PI). Transmission electron microscopy was used to generate images identifying the biological effects of different treatments using ultrasound and ozone on bacterial cell walls. Results demonstrated that treatment with ozone alone (0.5 mg/l) resulted in a significant reduction (93%) in the number of live cells after 16 minutes treatment whereas ultrasound alone showed only a small reduction (24%). However a combination of ozone and ultrasound showed a synergistic effect and enhanced the inactivation to 99%. Conclusion: A combined ultrasound and ozone treatment of bacterial suspensions using a commercial system (USS, Ultrasonic Systems Gmbh) affords a promising method for water disinfection that is better than treatment using either method alone. Standard viable plate count analysis is normally used to assess the effectiveness of disinfection treatments; however flow cytometry proved to be a more sensitive method to determine the actual effects in terms of not only live and dead cells but also damaged cells. This type of analysis (cell damage) is difficult if not impossible to achieve using traditional plate counting methodology.

KW - ultrasound

KW - ozone

KW - biological disinfection

KW - water treatment

KW - water disinfection

U2 - 10.1021/es5045437

DO - 10.1021/es5045437

M3 - Article

VL - 49

SP - 11697

EP - 11702

JO - Environmental Science & Technology

JF - Environmental Science & Technology

SN - 0013-936X

IS - 19

ER -