Patient safety incident reporting in Indonesia: an analysis using World Health Organization characteristics for successful reporting

Inge Dhamanti, Sandra Leggat, Simon Barraclough, Benny Tjahjono

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Incident reporting is widely acknowledged as one of the ways of improving patient safety and has been implemented in Indonesia for more than ten years. However, there was no significant increase in the number of reported incidents nationally. The study described in this paper aimed at assessing the extent to which Indonesia’s patient safety incident reporting system has adhered to the World Health Organization (WHO) characteristics for successful reporting.
Methods:
We interviewed officials from 16 organizations at national, provincial and district or city levels in Indonesia. We reviewed several policies, guidelines and regulations pertinent to incident reporting in Indonesia and examined whether the WHO characteristics were covered in these documents. We used NVivo version 9 to manage the interview data and applied thematic analysis to organize our findings.
Results: Our study found that there was an increased need for a non-punitive system, confidentiality, expert-analysis, and timeliness of reporting, system-orientation, and responsiveness. The existing guidelines, policies and regulations in Indonesia, to a large extent, have not satisfied all the required WHO characteristics of incident reporting. Furthermore, awareness and understanding of the reporting system amongst officials at almost all levels were lacking.
Conclusion: Despite being implemented for more than a decade, Indonesia’s patient safety incident reporting system has not fully adhered to the WHO guidelines. There is a pressing need for the Indonesian Government to improve the system, by putting specific regulations and by creating a robust infrastructure at all levels to support the incident reporting.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)(In-press)
JournalRisk Management and Healthcare Policy
Volume(In-press)
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 3 Nov 2019

Fingerprint

Indonesia
Risk Management
Patient Safety
Guidelines
Expert Systems
Confidentiality
Organizations
Interviews

Keywords

  • patient safety
  • incident reporting
  • WHO guidelines

Cite this

Patient safety incident reporting in Indonesia: an analysis using World Health Organization characteristics for successful reporting. / Dhamanti, Inge; Leggat, Sandra; Barraclough, Simon; Tjahjono, Benny.

In: Risk Management and Healthcare Policy, Vol. (In-press), 03.11.2019, p. (In-press).

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{da4a113e48b640ed88ef25c8aced8f9a,
title = "Patient safety incident reporting in Indonesia: an analysis using World Health Organization characteristics for successful reporting",
abstract = "Background: Incident reporting is widely acknowledged as one of the ways of improving patient safety and has been implemented in Indonesia for more than ten years. However, there was no significant increase in the number of reported incidents nationally. The study described in this paper aimed at assessing the extent to which Indonesia’s patient safety incident reporting system has adhered to the World Health Organization (WHO) characteristics for successful reporting.Methods: We interviewed officials from 16 organizations at national, provincial and district or city levels in Indonesia. We reviewed several policies, guidelines and regulations pertinent to incident reporting in Indonesia and examined whether the WHO characteristics were covered in these documents. We used NVivo version 9 to manage the interview data and applied thematic analysis to organize our findings. Results: Our study found that there was an increased need for a non-punitive system, confidentiality, expert-analysis, and timeliness of reporting, system-orientation, and responsiveness. The existing guidelines, policies and regulations in Indonesia, to a large extent, have not satisfied all the required WHO characteristics of incident reporting. Furthermore, awareness and understanding of the reporting system amongst officials at almost all levels were lacking. Conclusion: Despite being implemented for more than a decade, Indonesia’s patient safety incident reporting system has not fully adhered to the WHO guidelines. There is a pressing need for the Indonesian Government to improve the system, by putting specific regulations and by creating a robust infrastructure at all levels to support the incident reporting.",
keywords = "patient safety, incident reporting, WHO guidelines",
author = "Inge Dhamanti and Sandra Leggat and Simon Barraclough and Benny Tjahjono",
year = "2019",
month = "11",
day = "3",
language = "English",
volume = "(In-press)",
pages = "(In--press)",
journal = "Risk Management and Healthcare Policy",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Patient safety incident reporting in Indonesia: an analysis using World Health Organization characteristics for successful reporting

AU - Dhamanti, Inge

AU - Leggat, Sandra

AU - Barraclough, Simon

AU - Tjahjono, Benny

PY - 2019/11/3

Y1 - 2019/11/3

N2 - Background: Incident reporting is widely acknowledged as one of the ways of improving patient safety and has been implemented in Indonesia for more than ten years. However, there was no significant increase in the number of reported incidents nationally. The study described in this paper aimed at assessing the extent to which Indonesia’s patient safety incident reporting system has adhered to the World Health Organization (WHO) characteristics for successful reporting.Methods: We interviewed officials from 16 organizations at national, provincial and district or city levels in Indonesia. We reviewed several policies, guidelines and regulations pertinent to incident reporting in Indonesia and examined whether the WHO characteristics were covered in these documents. We used NVivo version 9 to manage the interview data and applied thematic analysis to organize our findings. Results: Our study found that there was an increased need for a non-punitive system, confidentiality, expert-analysis, and timeliness of reporting, system-orientation, and responsiveness. The existing guidelines, policies and regulations in Indonesia, to a large extent, have not satisfied all the required WHO characteristics of incident reporting. Furthermore, awareness and understanding of the reporting system amongst officials at almost all levels were lacking. Conclusion: Despite being implemented for more than a decade, Indonesia’s patient safety incident reporting system has not fully adhered to the WHO guidelines. There is a pressing need for the Indonesian Government to improve the system, by putting specific regulations and by creating a robust infrastructure at all levels to support the incident reporting.

AB - Background: Incident reporting is widely acknowledged as one of the ways of improving patient safety and has been implemented in Indonesia for more than ten years. However, there was no significant increase in the number of reported incidents nationally. The study described in this paper aimed at assessing the extent to which Indonesia’s patient safety incident reporting system has adhered to the World Health Organization (WHO) characteristics for successful reporting.Methods: We interviewed officials from 16 organizations at national, provincial and district or city levels in Indonesia. We reviewed several policies, guidelines and regulations pertinent to incident reporting in Indonesia and examined whether the WHO characteristics were covered in these documents. We used NVivo version 9 to manage the interview data and applied thematic analysis to organize our findings. Results: Our study found that there was an increased need for a non-punitive system, confidentiality, expert-analysis, and timeliness of reporting, system-orientation, and responsiveness. The existing guidelines, policies and regulations in Indonesia, to a large extent, have not satisfied all the required WHO characteristics of incident reporting. Furthermore, awareness and understanding of the reporting system amongst officials at almost all levels were lacking. Conclusion: Despite being implemented for more than a decade, Indonesia’s patient safety incident reporting system has not fully adhered to the WHO guidelines. There is a pressing need for the Indonesian Government to improve the system, by putting specific regulations and by creating a robust infrastructure at all levels to support the incident reporting.

KW - patient safety

KW - incident reporting

KW - WHO guidelines

M3 - Article

VL - (In-press)

SP - (In-press)

JO - Risk Management and Healthcare Policy

JF - Risk Management and Healthcare Policy

ER -