Make me authentic, but not here: Reflexive struggles with academic identity and authentic leadership

L. Tomkins, Alyson Nicholds

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)
29 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This article presents a reflexive auto-ethnography of the experience of teaching authentic leadership to MBA students. It traces parallels between the challenges of authentic leadership and the challenges of academic identity work, grounded specifically in the experience of having to teach something one does not fully endorse. Both authentic leadership and academic identity work emerge as struggle – riddled with false starts, best intentions and self-deception, and entwined in the politics of pragmatism, idealism, ambition and survival. The subject position of the mature entrant to academia who is also an ‘early career scholar’ is likened to an awkward adolescent, experimenting with shades of independence/dependence, resistance/compliance and voice/silence. Based on these reflections, having authentic leadership on the curriculum involves a particular kind of identity regulation for students and academics alike, running counter to philosophical notions of authenticity as striving for one’s own way in the world. Authentic leadership will only flourish in the business school if academics muster the courage to acknowledge its relevance for our own role as teacher-leaders, rather than simply teaching or writing to its abstract, ideological appeal.
Original languageEnglish
JournalManagement Learning
Volume(in press)
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12 Jan 2017

Fingerprint

Teaching
Students
Curricula
Industry
Authentic leadership
Compliance
Identity work

Bibliographical note

This article is currently in press. Full citation details will be uploaded when available.

Keywords

  • Authenticity
  • existentialism
  • identity
  • leadership
  • reflexivity
  • resistance
  • teacher-leader

Cite this

Make me authentic, but not here: Reflexive struggles with academic identity and authentic leadership. / Tomkins, L.; Nicholds, Alyson.

In: Management Learning, Vol. (in press), 12.01.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{5d8864b30950484f8df39221662ad59a,
title = "Make me authentic, but not here: Reflexive struggles with academic identity and authentic leadership",
abstract = "This article presents a reflexive auto-ethnography of the experience of teaching authentic leadership to MBA students. It traces parallels between the challenges of authentic leadership and the challenges of academic identity work, grounded specifically in the experience of having to teach something one does not fully endorse. Both authentic leadership and academic identity work emerge as struggle – riddled with false starts, best intentions and self-deception, and entwined in the politics of pragmatism, idealism, ambition and survival. The subject position of the mature entrant to academia who is also an ‘early career scholar’ is likened to an awkward adolescent, experimenting with shades of independence/dependence, resistance/compliance and voice/silence. Based on these reflections, having authentic leadership on the curriculum involves a particular kind of identity regulation for students and academics alike, running counter to philosophical notions of authenticity as striving for one’s own way in the world. Authentic leadership will only flourish in the business school if academics muster the courage to acknowledge its relevance for our own role as teacher-leaders, rather than simply teaching or writing to its abstract, ideological appeal.",
keywords = "Authenticity, existentialism, identity, leadership, reflexivity, resistance, teacher-leader",
author = "L. Tomkins and Alyson Nicholds",
note = "This article is currently in press. Full citation details will be uploaded when available.",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "12",
doi = "10.1177/1350507616684267",
language = "English",
volume = "(in press)",
journal = "Management Learning",
issn = "1350-5076",
publisher = "SAGE Publications",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Make me authentic, but not here: Reflexive struggles with academic identity and authentic leadership

AU - Tomkins, L.

AU - Nicholds, Alyson

N1 - This article is currently in press. Full citation details will be uploaded when available.

PY - 2017/1/12

Y1 - 2017/1/12

N2 - This article presents a reflexive auto-ethnography of the experience of teaching authentic leadership to MBA students. It traces parallels between the challenges of authentic leadership and the challenges of academic identity work, grounded specifically in the experience of having to teach something one does not fully endorse. Both authentic leadership and academic identity work emerge as struggle – riddled with false starts, best intentions and self-deception, and entwined in the politics of pragmatism, idealism, ambition and survival. The subject position of the mature entrant to academia who is also an ‘early career scholar’ is likened to an awkward adolescent, experimenting with shades of independence/dependence, resistance/compliance and voice/silence. Based on these reflections, having authentic leadership on the curriculum involves a particular kind of identity regulation for students and academics alike, running counter to philosophical notions of authenticity as striving for one’s own way in the world. Authentic leadership will only flourish in the business school if academics muster the courage to acknowledge its relevance for our own role as teacher-leaders, rather than simply teaching or writing to its abstract, ideological appeal.

AB - This article presents a reflexive auto-ethnography of the experience of teaching authentic leadership to MBA students. It traces parallels between the challenges of authentic leadership and the challenges of academic identity work, grounded specifically in the experience of having to teach something one does not fully endorse. Both authentic leadership and academic identity work emerge as struggle – riddled with false starts, best intentions and self-deception, and entwined in the politics of pragmatism, idealism, ambition and survival. The subject position of the mature entrant to academia who is also an ‘early career scholar’ is likened to an awkward adolescent, experimenting with shades of independence/dependence, resistance/compliance and voice/silence. Based on these reflections, having authentic leadership on the curriculum involves a particular kind of identity regulation for students and academics alike, running counter to philosophical notions of authenticity as striving for one’s own way in the world. Authentic leadership will only flourish in the business school if academics muster the courage to acknowledge its relevance for our own role as teacher-leaders, rather than simply teaching or writing to its abstract, ideological appeal.

KW - Authenticity

KW - existentialism

KW - identity

KW - leadership

KW - reflexivity

KW - resistance

KW - teacher-leader

U2 - 10.1177/1350507616684267

DO - 10.1177/1350507616684267

M3 - Article

VL - (in press)

JO - Management Learning

JF - Management Learning

SN - 1350-5076

ER -