"I am quite a genuine person”: Sales training and the limits of moulding instrumentality

Konstantinos Kakavelakis, Alan Felstead, Alison Fuller, Nick Jewson, Lorna Unwin

Research output: Working paper

Abstract

Sales work is a key feature of the contemporary service economy which has prompted considerable academic debate. This has centred on the processes of standardization exemplified by sales routines and scripts. It is frequently suggested that these management devices are unproblematically embraced by workers who share a mutual interest with management in controlling customer behaviour and masking the contradictions of simultaneously displaying empathy while ‘closing the deal’. In these accounts, sales workers are denied agency. This paper questions this assumption by presenting empirical evidence from a case
study of sales advisors in a large chain of private fitness clubs whose job is to sell annual memberships. The research involved eight interviews with trainers and managers at head office. We were also able to tape record and participate in a five day training course that all newly appointed sales advisors have to attend. We carried out interviews with all eight trainees a couple of months after the end of the course. This allowed us to follow the path of newly appointed sales advisors by hearing, seeing and experiencing the training they receive, and then
gathering data on the extent to which the training is followed on the ground. The data show that although the training course placed strong emphasis on routines designed to control customers and maximize the commission received by sales advisors, once back on ‘home’ territory advisors often chose to approach customers with less instrumentality. This contrast is explained by reference to the advisors’ past dispositions and experiences, and to the specific local conditions in which sales take place.
Original languageEnglish
PublisherCardiff University
Pages1-25
Number of pages24
Publication statusPublished - 1 Aug 2007

Publication series

NameLearning as Work Research Paper No11
PublisherCardiff School of Social Sciences, Cardiff University

Fingerprint

Advisors
Sales training
Instrumentality
Workers
Empirical evidence
Empathy
Customer behavior
Clubs
Standardization
Service economy
Fitness
Managers
Disposition

Cite this

Kakavelakis, K., Felstead, A., Fuller, A., Jewson, N., & Unwin, L. (2007). "I am quite a genuine person”: Sales training and the limits of moulding instrumentality. (pp. 1-25). (Learning as Work Research Paper No11). Cardiff University.

"I am quite a genuine person”: Sales training and the limits of moulding instrumentality. / Kakavelakis, Konstantinos; Felstead, Alan; Fuller, Alison ; Jewson, Nick; Unwin, Lorna.

Cardiff University, 2007. p. 1-25 (Learning as Work Research Paper No11).

Research output: Working paper

Kakavelakis, K, Felstead, A, Fuller, A, Jewson, N & Unwin, L 2007 '"I am quite a genuine person”: Sales training and the limits of moulding instrumentality' Learning as Work Research Paper No11, Cardiff University, pp. 1-25.
Kakavelakis K, Felstead A, Fuller A, Jewson N, Unwin L. "I am quite a genuine person”: Sales training and the limits of moulding instrumentality. Cardiff University. 2007 Aug 1, p. 1-25. (Learning as Work Research Paper No11).
Kakavelakis, Konstantinos ; Felstead, Alan ; Fuller, Alison ; Jewson, Nick ; Unwin, Lorna. / "I am quite a genuine person”: Sales training and the limits of moulding instrumentality. Cardiff University, 2007. pp. 1-25 (Learning as Work Research Paper No11).
@techreport{5a171c866907487b85b4b6e92ae6a813,
title = "{"}I am quite a genuine person”: Sales training and the limits of moulding instrumentality",
abstract = "Sales work is a key feature of the contemporary service economy which has prompted considerable academic debate. This has centred on the processes of standardization exemplified by sales routines and scripts. It is frequently suggested that these management devices are unproblematically embraced by workers who share a mutual interest with management in controlling customer behaviour and masking the contradictions of simultaneously displaying empathy while ‘closing the deal’. In these accounts, sales workers are denied agency. This paper questions this assumption by presenting empirical evidence from a casestudy of sales advisors in a large chain of private fitness clubs whose job is to sell annual memberships. The research involved eight interviews with trainers and managers at head office. We were also able to tape record and participate in a five day training course that all newly appointed sales advisors have to attend. We carried out interviews with all eight trainees a couple of months after the end of the course. This allowed us to follow the path of newly appointed sales advisors by hearing, seeing and experiencing the training they receive, and thengathering data on the extent to which the training is followed on the ground. The data show that although the training course placed strong emphasis on routines designed to control customers and maximize the commission received by sales advisors, once back on ‘home’ territory advisors often chose to approach customers with less instrumentality. This contrast is explained by reference to the advisors’ past dispositions and experiences, and to the specific local conditions in which sales take place.",
author = "Konstantinos Kakavelakis and Alan Felstead and Alison Fuller and Nick Jewson and Lorna Unwin",
year = "2007",
month = "8",
day = "1",
language = "English",
series = "Learning as Work Research Paper No11",
publisher = "Cardiff University",
pages = "1--25",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "Cardiff University",

}

TY - UNPB

T1 - "I am quite a genuine person”: Sales training and the limits of moulding instrumentality

AU - Kakavelakis, Konstantinos

AU - Felstead, Alan

AU - Fuller, Alison

AU - Jewson, Nick

AU - Unwin, Lorna

PY - 2007/8/1

Y1 - 2007/8/1

N2 - Sales work is a key feature of the contemporary service economy which has prompted considerable academic debate. This has centred on the processes of standardization exemplified by sales routines and scripts. It is frequently suggested that these management devices are unproblematically embraced by workers who share a mutual interest with management in controlling customer behaviour and masking the contradictions of simultaneously displaying empathy while ‘closing the deal’. In these accounts, sales workers are denied agency. This paper questions this assumption by presenting empirical evidence from a casestudy of sales advisors in a large chain of private fitness clubs whose job is to sell annual memberships. The research involved eight interviews with trainers and managers at head office. We were also able to tape record and participate in a five day training course that all newly appointed sales advisors have to attend. We carried out interviews with all eight trainees a couple of months after the end of the course. This allowed us to follow the path of newly appointed sales advisors by hearing, seeing and experiencing the training they receive, and thengathering data on the extent to which the training is followed on the ground. The data show that although the training course placed strong emphasis on routines designed to control customers and maximize the commission received by sales advisors, once back on ‘home’ territory advisors often chose to approach customers with less instrumentality. This contrast is explained by reference to the advisors’ past dispositions and experiences, and to the specific local conditions in which sales take place.

AB - Sales work is a key feature of the contemporary service economy which has prompted considerable academic debate. This has centred on the processes of standardization exemplified by sales routines and scripts. It is frequently suggested that these management devices are unproblematically embraced by workers who share a mutual interest with management in controlling customer behaviour and masking the contradictions of simultaneously displaying empathy while ‘closing the deal’. In these accounts, sales workers are denied agency. This paper questions this assumption by presenting empirical evidence from a casestudy of sales advisors in a large chain of private fitness clubs whose job is to sell annual memberships. The research involved eight interviews with trainers and managers at head office. We were also able to tape record and participate in a five day training course that all newly appointed sales advisors have to attend. We carried out interviews with all eight trainees a couple of months after the end of the course. This allowed us to follow the path of newly appointed sales advisors by hearing, seeing and experiencing the training they receive, and thengathering data on the extent to which the training is followed on the ground. The data show that although the training course placed strong emphasis on routines designed to control customers and maximize the commission received by sales advisors, once back on ‘home’ territory advisors often chose to approach customers with less instrumentality. This contrast is explained by reference to the advisors’ past dispositions and experiences, and to the specific local conditions in which sales take place.

M3 - Working paper

T3 - Learning as Work Research Paper No11

SP - 1

EP - 25

BT - "I am quite a genuine person”: Sales training and the limits of moulding instrumentality

PB - Cardiff University

ER -