G59 (P) long-term psychological and social impact reported by childhood critical illness survivors: a systematic review and thematic synthesis

JC Manning, P Hemingway, S Redsell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Aims Over 250,000 children annually in the US and UK experience critical illnesses. Advances in medicine and care have significantly reduced mortality, with over 95% of patients that survive. However, the long term psychological and social impact, as reported by children and adolescents that survive critical illness, is unclear. This paper reports a systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative literature that aims to explore and understand these phenomena.

Methods CINAHL; MEDLINE; PMC; PsychINFO; ASSIA and Dissertation and Thesis Databases were searched between 1806 and February 2012. Studies were selected using eight predetermined criteria (e.g. only qualitative empirical studies) and methodological quality was assessed using two standardised checklists (1, 2). Thematic synthesis (3) was used to extract, code and synthesise data.

Results From the 1307 studies identified, three met the inclusion criteria which were all of moderate methodological quality. All included studies were conducted in the UK involving a total of 51 participants aged 1–25 years. Reasons for participant critical illness were predominantly due to head/spinal injury, sepsis, or malignancies.

Eighty-six codes and six novel themes emerged from the data. Themes included: confusion and uncertainty; other people’s narratives; focus on former self and normality; social isolation and loss of identity; transition and transformation. Analytical synthesis culminated in a framework which attempts to conceptualise the childhood survivors’ journey.

Conclusions Childhood critical illness can expose survivors to a complex trajectory of recovery with residual psychosocial adversity manifesting in the long-term. Health professionals need to comprehend and support the potential complex psychological and social needs that may occur. Further empirical research is required to explore and test the conceptual framework developed from this thematic synthesis.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)A31
Number of pages1
JournalArchives of Disease in Childhood
Volume98
Issue numberSuppl 1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2013
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Social Change
Critical Illness
Survivors
Psychology
Spinal Injuries
Confusion
Social Isolation
Empirical Research
Checklist
Craniocerebral Trauma
MEDLINE
Uncertainty
Sepsis
Medicine
Databases
Mortality
Health
Neoplasms

Cite this

G59 (P) long-term psychological and social impact reported by childhood critical illness survivors: a systematic review and thematic synthesis. / Manning, JC; Hemingway, P; Redsell, S.

In: Archives of Disease in Childhood, Vol. 98, No. Suppl 1, 2013, p. A31.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{c081e8428d4a446bace3506d9c250dde,
title = "G59 (P) long-term psychological and social impact reported by childhood critical illness survivors: a systematic review and thematic synthesis",
abstract = "Aims Over 250,000 children annually in the US and UK experience critical illnesses. Advances in medicine and care have significantly reduced mortality, with over 95{\%} of patients that survive. However, the long term psychological and social impact, as reported by children and adolescents that survive critical illness, is unclear. This paper reports a systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative literature that aims to explore and understand these phenomena.Methods CINAHL; MEDLINE; PMC; PsychINFO; ASSIA and Dissertation and Thesis Databases were searched between 1806 and February 2012. Studies were selected using eight predetermined criteria (e.g. only qualitative empirical studies) and methodological quality was assessed using two standardised checklists (1, 2). Thematic synthesis (3) was used to extract, code and synthesise data.Results From the 1307 studies identified, three met the inclusion criteria which were all of moderate methodological quality. All included studies were conducted in the UK involving a total of 51 participants aged 1–25 years. Reasons for participant critical illness were predominantly due to head/spinal injury, sepsis, or malignancies.Eighty-six codes and six novel themes emerged from the data. Themes included: confusion and uncertainty; other people’s narratives; focus on former self and normality; social isolation and loss of identity; transition and transformation. Analytical synthesis culminated in a framework which attempts to conceptualise the childhood survivors’ journey.Conclusions Childhood critical illness can expose survivors to a complex trajectory of recovery with residual psychosocial adversity manifesting in the long-term. Health professionals need to comprehend and support the potential complex psychological and social needs that may occur. Further empirical research is required to explore and test the conceptual framework developed from this thematic synthesis.",
author = "JC Manning and P Hemingway and S Redsell",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1136/archdischild-2013-304107.071",
language = "English",
volume = "98",
pages = "A31",
journal = "Archives of Disease in Childhood",
issn = "0003-9888",
publisher = "BMJ Publishing Group Ltd",
number = "Suppl 1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - G59 (P) long-term psychological and social impact reported by childhood critical illness survivors: a systematic review and thematic synthesis

AU - Manning, JC

AU - Hemingway, P

AU - Redsell, S

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Aims Over 250,000 children annually in the US and UK experience critical illnesses. Advances in medicine and care have significantly reduced mortality, with over 95% of patients that survive. However, the long term psychological and social impact, as reported by children and adolescents that survive critical illness, is unclear. This paper reports a systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative literature that aims to explore and understand these phenomena.Methods CINAHL; MEDLINE; PMC; PsychINFO; ASSIA and Dissertation and Thesis Databases were searched between 1806 and February 2012. Studies were selected using eight predetermined criteria (e.g. only qualitative empirical studies) and methodological quality was assessed using two standardised checklists (1, 2). Thematic synthesis (3) was used to extract, code and synthesise data.Results From the 1307 studies identified, three met the inclusion criteria which were all of moderate methodological quality. All included studies were conducted in the UK involving a total of 51 participants aged 1–25 years. Reasons for participant critical illness were predominantly due to head/spinal injury, sepsis, or malignancies.Eighty-six codes and six novel themes emerged from the data. Themes included: confusion and uncertainty; other people’s narratives; focus on former self and normality; social isolation and loss of identity; transition and transformation. Analytical synthesis culminated in a framework which attempts to conceptualise the childhood survivors’ journey.Conclusions Childhood critical illness can expose survivors to a complex trajectory of recovery with residual psychosocial adversity manifesting in the long-term. Health professionals need to comprehend and support the potential complex psychological and social needs that may occur. Further empirical research is required to explore and test the conceptual framework developed from this thematic synthesis.

AB - Aims Over 250,000 children annually in the US and UK experience critical illnesses. Advances in medicine and care have significantly reduced mortality, with over 95% of patients that survive. However, the long term psychological and social impact, as reported by children and adolescents that survive critical illness, is unclear. This paper reports a systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative literature that aims to explore and understand these phenomena.Methods CINAHL; MEDLINE; PMC; PsychINFO; ASSIA and Dissertation and Thesis Databases were searched between 1806 and February 2012. Studies were selected using eight predetermined criteria (e.g. only qualitative empirical studies) and methodological quality was assessed using two standardised checklists (1, 2). Thematic synthesis (3) was used to extract, code and synthesise data.Results From the 1307 studies identified, three met the inclusion criteria which were all of moderate methodological quality. All included studies were conducted in the UK involving a total of 51 participants aged 1–25 years. Reasons for participant critical illness were predominantly due to head/spinal injury, sepsis, or malignancies.Eighty-six codes and six novel themes emerged from the data. Themes included: confusion and uncertainty; other people’s narratives; focus on former self and normality; social isolation and loss of identity; transition and transformation. Analytical synthesis culminated in a framework which attempts to conceptualise the childhood survivors’ journey.Conclusions Childhood critical illness can expose survivors to a complex trajectory of recovery with residual psychosocial adversity manifesting in the long-term. Health professionals need to comprehend and support the potential complex psychological and social needs that may occur. Further empirical research is required to explore and test the conceptual framework developed from this thematic synthesis.

U2 - 10.1136/archdischild-2013-304107.071

DO - 10.1136/archdischild-2013-304107.071

M3 - Article

VL - 98

SP - A31

JO - Archives of Disease in Childhood

JF - Archives of Disease in Childhood

SN - 0003-9888

IS - Suppl 1

ER -