Futures, ethics and the politics of expectation in biodiversity conservation: A case study of South African sustainable wildflower harvesting

C. McEwan, A. Hughes, David Bek

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)
17 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Corporate efforts to demonstrate ‘sustainability’ within production networks are driving a continued demand for new metrics. This raises questions concerning which experts will be enlisted in their creation, what data and calculative methods they will draw on, and how and whether different publics will be convinced of the rigour of these metrics and their ethical purpose. Debates about futures and expectations tend to be western-centric; in response, this paper highlights the sophisticated environmental science and knowledges in a global South context where politics and uncertainty are of utmost importance. It draws on research into sustainable wild flower harvesting in the Cape Floral Kingdom (CFK), in the Western Cape province of South Africa, to explore the politics of expectation and future-making driving debates about biodiversity conservation and socio-economic empowerment within rural communities. It focuses specifically on how expectations of technologies, databases, knowledge and the environment play out in this particular site of production, influencing debates about sustainability, but also perspectives on what is ethical. The case study demonstrates that expectations are neither uniform nor uncontested, but bound up with inequities of power and authority in defining futures. The paper draws on postcolonial approaches to conclude that a radical opening of databases and knowledge production might challenge these asymmetries, but that constraints exist because of external pressures and expectations that arise from the political economy of biodiversity conservation.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)206-215
JournalGeoforum
Volume52
Early online date7 Nov 2012
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2014

Fingerprint

biodiversity
conservation
moral philosophy
politics
sustainability
knowledge production
asymmetry
rural community
empowerment
political economy
uncertainty
expert
demand
science
economics

Keywords

  • Biodiversity
  • Conservation
  • Database
  • Ethics
  • Futures
  • South Africa
  • Postcolonialism
  • Fynbos

Cite this

Futures, ethics and the politics of expectation in biodiversity conservation: A case study of South African sustainable wildflower harvesting. / McEwan, C.; Hughes, A.; Bek, David.

In: Geoforum, Vol. 52, 03.2014, p. 206-215.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{348aa119fb87411b8ec433823ea86711,
title = "Futures, ethics and the politics of expectation in biodiversity conservation: A case study of South African sustainable wildflower harvesting",
abstract = "Corporate efforts to demonstrate ‘sustainability’ within production networks are driving a continued demand for new metrics. This raises questions concerning which experts will be enlisted in their creation, what data and calculative methods they will draw on, and how and whether different publics will be convinced of the rigour of these metrics and their ethical purpose. Debates about futures and expectations tend to be western-centric; in response, this paper highlights the sophisticated environmental science and knowledges in a global South context where politics and uncertainty are of utmost importance. It draws on research into sustainable wild flower harvesting in the Cape Floral Kingdom (CFK), in the Western Cape province of South Africa, to explore the politics of expectation and future-making driving debates about biodiversity conservation and socio-economic empowerment within rural communities. It focuses specifically on how expectations of technologies, databases, knowledge and the environment play out in this particular site of production, influencing debates about sustainability, but also perspectives on what is ethical. The case study demonstrates that expectations are neither uniform nor uncontested, but bound up with inequities of power and authority in defining futures. The paper draws on postcolonial approaches to conclude that a radical opening of databases and knowledge production might challenge these asymmetries, but that constraints exist because of external pressures and expectations that arise from the political economy of biodiversity conservation.",
keywords = "Biodiversity, Conservation, Database, Ethics, Futures, South Africa, Postcolonialism, Fynbos",
author = "C. McEwan and A. Hughes and David Bek",
year = "2014",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1016/j.geoforum.2012.09.010",
language = "English",
volume = "52",
pages = "206--215",
journal = "Geoforum",
issn = "0016-7185",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Futures, ethics and the politics of expectation in biodiversity conservation: A case study of South African sustainable wildflower harvesting

AU - McEwan, C.

AU - Hughes, A.

AU - Bek, David

PY - 2014/3

Y1 - 2014/3

N2 - Corporate efforts to demonstrate ‘sustainability’ within production networks are driving a continued demand for new metrics. This raises questions concerning which experts will be enlisted in their creation, what data and calculative methods they will draw on, and how and whether different publics will be convinced of the rigour of these metrics and their ethical purpose. Debates about futures and expectations tend to be western-centric; in response, this paper highlights the sophisticated environmental science and knowledges in a global South context where politics and uncertainty are of utmost importance. It draws on research into sustainable wild flower harvesting in the Cape Floral Kingdom (CFK), in the Western Cape province of South Africa, to explore the politics of expectation and future-making driving debates about biodiversity conservation and socio-economic empowerment within rural communities. It focuses specifically on how expectations of technologies, databases, knowledge and the environment play out in this particular site of production, influencing debates about sustainability, but also perspectives on what is ethical. The case study demonstrates that expectations are neither uniform nor uncontested, but bound up with inequities of power and authority in defining futures. The paper draws on postcolonial approaches to conclude that a radical opening of databases and knowledge production might challenge these asymmetries, but that constraints exist because of external pressures and expectations that arise from the political economy of biodiversity conservation.

AB - Corporate efforts to demonstrate ‘sustainability’ within production networks are driving a continued demand for new metrics. This raises questions concerning which experts will be enlisted in their creation, what data and calculative methods they will draw on, and how and whether different publics will be convinced of the rigour of these metrics and their ethical purpose. Debates about futures and expectations tend to be western-centric; in response, this paper highlights the sophisticated environmental science and knowledges in a global South context where politics and uncertainty are of utmost importance. It draws on research into sustainable wild flower harvesting in the Cape Floral Kingdom (CFK), in the Western Cape province of South Africa, to explore the politics of expectation and future-making driving debates about biodiversity conservation and socio-economic empowerment within rural communities. It focuses specifically on how expectations of technologies, databases, knowledge and the environment play out in this particular site of production, influencing debates about sustainability, but also perspectives on what is ethical. The case study demonstrates that expectations are neither uniform nor uncontested, but bound up with inequities of power and authority in defining futures. The paper draws on postcolonial approaches to conclude that a radical opening of databases and knowledge production might challenge these asymmetries, but that constraints exist because of external pressures and expectations that arise from the political economy of biodiversity conservation.

KW - Biodiversity

KW - Conservation

KW - Database

KW - Ethics

KW - Futures

KW - South Africa

KW - Postcolonialism

KW - Fynbos

U2 - 10.1016/j.geoforum.2012.09.010

DO - 10.1016/j.geoforum.2012.09.010

M3 - Article

VL - 52

SP - 206

EP - 215

JO - Geoforum

JF - Geoforum

SN - 0016-7185

ER -