Fairtrade, place and moral economy: between abstract ethical discourse and the moral experience of Northern Cape farmers

Cheryl McEwan, Alex Hughes, David Bek

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

41 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This paper explores the significance of the relationships and disjunctures between the global moral discourses of Fairtrade that are articulated through ethics of fairness in supply chains and the everyday moral experiences, discourses and practices of producers that shape moral economies in specific localities. Due to increased governance through universal codes, standards and certification, Fairtrade risks becoming an abstract ethical and regulatory tool, disconnected from the moral economies of those poor farmers it is intended to benefit. In response, the paper makes a case for a deeper understanding of the moral economies of farmers involved in Fairtrade networks and the ways in which these emerge out of moral experiences that are deeply embedded in local social and cultural relations. Through a case study of Eksteenskuil Agricultural Cooperative in South Africa’s Northern Cape, it seeks to demonstrate the importance of understanding the moral experiences of producers to better consider what is at stake for them, focusing on notions of cooperation, fairness and the ‘good farmer’, perceptions of community, and concerns with survival and self-sufficiency. The paper concludes that working in culturally-sensitive ways with producer communities and understanding how their local moral worlds are structured is vital in bridging the gap between abstract ethical discourses and the place-based moral experiences of producers, and to ensuring the effectiveness of Fairtrade initiatives.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)572-591
Number of pages20
JournalEnvironment and Planning A
Volume49
Issue number3
Early online date17 Oct 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Fingerprint

producer
farmer
economy
discourse
cultural relations
agricultural cooperative
fairness
experience
self sufficiency
certification
ethics
self-sufficiency
Social Relations
community
moral philosophy
governance
supply
world
code
Africa

Bibliographical note

© Sage

Keywords

  • Cooperatives
  • ethics
  • Fairtrade
  • moral experience
  • South Africa

Cite this

Fairtrade, place and moral economy: between abstract ethical discourse and the moral experience of Northern Cape farmers. / McEwan, Cheryl; Hughes, Alex; Bek, David.

In: Environment and Planning A, Vol. 49, No. 3, 2017, p. 572-591.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{51c9720e8a6b43d9a7ba904d2af2e671,
title = "Fairtrade, place and moral economy: between abstract ethical discourse and the moral experience of Northern Cape farmers",
abstract = "This paper explores the significance of the relationships and disjunctures between the global moral discourses of Fairtrade that are articulated through ethics of fairness in supply chains and the everyday moral experiences, discourses and practices of producers that shape moral economies in specific localities. Due to increased governance through universal codes, standards and certification, Fairtrade risks becoming an abstract ethical and regulatory tool, disconnected from the moral economies of those poor farmers it is intended to benefit. In response, the paper makes a case for a deeper understanding of the moral economies of farmers involved in Fairtrade networks and the ways in which these emerge out of moral experiences that are deeply embedded in local social and cultural relations. Through a case study of Eksteenskuil Agricultural Cooperative in South Africa’s Northern Cape, it seeks to demonstrate the importance of understanding the moral experiences of producers to better consider what is at stake for them, focusing on notions of cooperation, fairness and the ‘good farmer’, perceptions of community, and concerns with survival and self-sufficiency. The paper concludes that working in culturally-sensitive ways with producer communities and understanding how their local moral worlds are structured is vital in bridging the gap between abstract ethical discourses and the place-based moral experiences of producers, and to ensuring the effectiveness of Fairtrade initiatives.",
keywords = "Cooperatives, ethics, Fairtrade, moral experience, South Africa",
author = "Cheryl McEwan and Alex Hughes and David Bek",
note = "{\circledC} Sage",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.1177/0308518x16674722",
language = "English",
volume = "49",
pages = "572--591",
journal = "Environment and Planning A",
issn = "0308-518X",
publisher = "SAGE Publications",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Fairtrade, place and moral economy: between abstract ethical discourse and the moral experience of Northern Cape farmers

AU - McEwan, Cheryl

AU - Hughes, Alex

AU - Bek, David

N1 - © Sage

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - This paper explores the significance of the relationships and disjunctures between the global moral discourses of Fairtrade that are articulated through ethics of fairness in supply chains and the everyday moral experiences, discourses and practices of producers that shape moral economies in specific localities. Due to increased governance through universal codes, standards and certification, Fairtrade risks becoming an abstract ethical and regulatory tool, disconnected from the moral economies of those poor farmers it is intended to benefit. In response, the paper makes a case for a deeper understanding of the moral economies of farmers involved in Fairtrade networks and the ways in which these emerge out of moral experiences that are deeply embedded in local social and cultural relations. Through a case study of Eksteenskuil Agricultural Cooperative in South Africa’s Northern Cape, it seeks to demonstrate the importance of understanding the moral experiences of producers to better consider what is at stake for them, focusing on notions of cooperation, fairness and the ‘good farmer’, perceptions of community, and concerns with survival and self-sufficiency. The paper concludes that working in culturally-sensitive ways with producer communities and understanding how their local moral worlds are structured is vital in bridging the gap between abstract ethical discourses and the place-based moral experiences of producers, and to ensuring the effectiveness of Fairtrade initiatives.

AB - This paper explores the significance of the relationships and disjunctures between the global moral discourses of Fairtrade that are articulated through ethics of fairness in supply chains and the everyday moral experiences, discourses and practices of producers that shape moral economies in specific localities. Due to increased governance through universal codes, standards and certification, Fairtrade risks becoming an abstract ethical and regulatory tool, disconnected from the moral economies of those poor farmers it is intended to benefit. In response, the paper makes a case for a deeper understanding of the moral economies of farmers involved in Fairtrade networks and the ways in which these emerge out of moral experiences that are deeply embedded in local social and cultural relations. Through a case study of Eksteenskuil Agricultural Cooperative in South Africa’s Northern Cape, it seeks to demonstrate the importance of understanding the moral experiences of producers to better consider what is at stake for them, focusing on notions of cooperation, fairness and the ‘good farmer’, perceptions of community, and concerns with survival and self-sufficiency. The paper concludes that working in culturally-sensitive ways with producer communities and understanding how their local moral worlds are structured is vital in bridging the gap between abstract ethical discourses and the place-based moral experiences of producers, and to ensuring the effectiveness of Fairtrade initiatives.

KW - Cooperatives

KW - ethics

KW - Fairtrade

KW - moral experience

KW - South Africa

U2 - 10.1177/0308518x16674722

DO - 10.1177/0308518x16674722

M3 - Article

VL - 49

SP - 572

EP - 591

JO - Environment and Planning A

JF - Environment and Planning A

SN - 0308-518X

IS - 3

ER -