Contesting Hydropower Dams in the Eastern Himalaya: The Cultural Politics of Identity, Territory and Self-Governance Institutions in Sikkim, India

Rinchu Doma Dukpa, Deepa Joshi, Rutgerd Boelens

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)
7 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

In India's Eastern Himalayan State of Sikkim, the indigenous Bhutia communities, Lachungpas and Lachenpas, successfully contested all proposed hydropower projects and have managed to sustain an anti-dam opposition in their home regions, Lachung and Lachen. In this paper, we discuss this remarkable, un-researched, effective collective action against hydropower development, examining how identity and territory influence collective action through production, creation and application of vernacular knowledge systems. The role of the Dzumsa, a prevailing traditional system of self-governance among the Lachungpas and Lachenpas, has been central in their collective resistance against large dams in Lachung and Lachen. Our findings show that contrary to popular imageries, the Dzumsa is neither an egalitarian nor a democratic institution-rather, it is an exercise of an "agonistic unity". The Dzumsas operate as complex collectives, which serve to politicize identity, decision-making and place-based territoriality in their struggle against internal and external threats. Principles of a "vernacular statecraft" helped bringing the local communities together in imperfect unions to oppose modernist designs of hydropower development. However, while such vernacular institutions were able to construct a powerful local adversary to neoliberal agendas, they also pose high social, political and emotional risks to the few within the community, who chose not to align with the normative principles of the collective.

Original languageEnglish
Article number412
Number of pages23
JournalWater (Switzerland)
Volume11
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 26 Feb 2019

Fingerprint

Sikkim
water power
politics
collective action
hydropower
governance
Politics
Dams
India
dam
collective behavior
territoriality
Territoriality
community
imagery
Decision making
Imagery (Psychotherapy)
decision making
Decision Making
exercise

Bibliographical note

This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution
(CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).

Keywords

  • Agonistic unity
  • Collective action
  • Dzumsa
  • Hydropower development
  • North Sikkim
  • Politicized collective identity
  • Territory
  • Vernacular statecraft

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biochemistry
  • Geography, Planning and Development
  • Aquatic Science
  • Water Science and Technology

Cite this

Contesting Hydropower Dams in the Eastern Himalaya: The Cultural Politics of Identity, Territory and Self-Governance Institutions in Sikkim, India. / Doma Dukpa, Rinchu; Joshi, Deepa; Boelens, Rutgerd.

In: Water (Switzerland), Vol. 11, No. 3, 412, 26.02.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{a9fa08eb5f8e4ef4a8ea892db1c01aa5,
title = "Contesting Hydropower Dams in the Eastern Himalaya: The Cultural Politics of Identity, Territory and Self-Governance Institutions in Sikkim, India",
abstract = "In India's Eastern Himalayan State of Sikkim, the indigenous Bhutia communities, Lachungpas and Lachenpas, successfully contested all proposed hydropower projects and have managed to sustain an anti-dam opposition in their home regions, Lachung and Lachen. In this paper, we discuss this remarkable, un-researched, effective collective action against hydropower development, examining how identity and territory influence collective action through production, creation and application of vernacular knowledge systems. The role of the Dzumsa, a prevailing traditional system of self-governance among the Lachungpas and Lachenpas, has been central in their collective resistance against large dams in Lachung and Lachen. Our findings show that contrary to popular imageries, the Dzumsa is neither an egalitarian nor a democratic institution-rather, it is an exercise of an {"}agonistic unity{"}. The Dzumsas operate as complex collectives, which serve to politicize identity, decision-making and place-based territoriality in their struggle against internal and external threats. Principles of a {"}vernacular statecraft{"} helped bringing the local communities together in imperfect unions to oppose modernist designs of hydropower development. However, while such vernacular institutions were able to construct a powerful local adversary to neoliberal agendas, they also pose high social, political and emotional risks to the few within the community, who chose not to align with the normative principles of the collective.",
keywords = "Agonistic unity, Collective action, Dzumsa, Hydropower development, North Sikkim, Politicized collective identity, Territory, Vernacular statecraft",
author = "{Doma Dukpa}, Rinchu and Deepa Joshi and Rutgerd Boelens",
note = "This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).",
year = "2019",
month = "2",
day = "26",
doi = "10.3390/w11030412",
language = "English",
volume = "11",
journal = "Water (Switzerland)",
issn = "2073-4441",
publisher = "MDPI",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Contesting Hydropower Dams in the Eastern Himalaya: The Cultural Politics of Identity, Territory and Self-Governance Institutions in Sikkim, India

AU - Doma Dukpa, Rinchu

AU - Joshi, Deepa

AU - Boelens, Rutgerd

N1 - This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).

PY - 2019/2/26

Y1 - 2019/2/26

N2 - In India's Eastern Himalayan State of Sikkim, the indigenous Bhutia communities, Lachungpas and Lachenpas, successfully contested all proposed hydropower projects and have managed to sustain an anti-dam opposition in their home regions, Lachung and Lachen. In this paper, we discuss this remarkable, un-researched, effective collective action against hydropower development, examining how identity and territory influence collective action through production, creation and application of vernacular knowledge systems. The role of the Dzumsa, a prevailing traditional system of self-governance among the Lachungpas and Lachenpas, has been central in their collective resistance against large dams in Lachung and Lachen. Our findings show that contrary to popular imageries, the Dzumsa is neither an egalitarian nor a democratic institution-rather, it is an exercise of an "agonistic unity". The Dzumsas operate as complex collectives, which serve to politicize identity, decision-making and place-based territoriality in their struggle against internal and external threats. Principles of a "vernacular statecraft" helped bringing the local communities together in imperfect unions to oppose modernist designs of hydropower development. However, while such vernacular institutions were able to construct a powerful local adversary to neoliberal agendas, they also pose high social, political and emotional risks to the few within the community, who chose not to align with the normative principles of the collective.

AB - In India's Eastern Himalayan State of Sikkim, the indigenous Bhutia communities, Lachungpas and Lachenpas, successfully contested all proposed hydropower projects and have managed to sustain an anti-dam opposition in their home regions, Lachung and Lachen. In this paper, we discuss this remarkable, un-researched, effective collective action against hydropower development, examining how identity and territory influence collective action through production, creation and application of vernacular knowledge systems. The role of the Dzumsa, a prevailing traditional system of self-governance among the Lachungpas and Lachenpas, has been central in their collective resistance against large dams in Lachung and Lachen. Our findings show that contrary to popular imageries, the Dzumsa is neither an egalitarian nor a democratic institution-rather, it is an exercise of an "agonistic unity". The Dzumsas operate as complex collectives, which serve to politicize identity, decision-making and place-based territoriality in their struggle against internal and external threats. Principles of a "vernacular statecraft" helped bringing the local communities together in imperfect unions to oppose modernist designs of hydropower development. However, while such vernacular institutions were able to construct a powerful local adversary to neoliberal agendas, they also pose high social, political and emotional risks to the few within the community, who chose not to align with the normative principles of the collective.

KW - Agonistic unity

KW - Collective action

KW - Dzumsa

KW - Hydropower development

KW - North Sikkim

KW - Politicized collective identity

KW - Territory

KW - Vernacular statecraft

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85064923501&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3390/w11030412

DO - 10.3390/w11030412

M3 - Article

VL - 11

JO - Water (Switzerland)

JF - Water (Switzerland)

SN - 2073-4441

IS - 3

M1 - 412

ER -