Collective Emotions in Celebratory, Competitive, and Conflictual Contexts: Exploring the Dynamic Relations between Group-Based and Collective Pride and Shame

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Pride and shame are typically viewed as diametrically opposed but dynamically related personal emotions that also occur in group-based and collective forms. Building upon seminal work by Cooley and Scheff to explain the generation and manifestation of these emotions in the imaginations and everyday realities of people’s social-relational individual and group lives, our analysis addresses contemporary developments in social and psychological science (Collins, Mackie & Smith, Reicher & Neville, Skey, Sullivan, von Scheve & Ismer, Wetherell), by highlighting patterns of complex, dynamic relations between occurrences of group-based pride, group-based shame, collective pride and collective shame in prototypical group contexts of celebration, competition and conflict. Our novel analysis includes underexplored group agency and performative details and we argue that mixtures of negative group pride and anger evident in collective hubris or contempt and some forms of aggression directed towards other groups are not necessarily produced by repression of collective shame.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)202-222
Number of pages21
JournalEmotions: History, culture, society
Volume3
Issue number2
Early online date15 Nov 2019
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 15 Nov 2019

Fingerprint

group relations
shame
emotion
Group
repression
anger
aggression

Funder

Not applicable

Keywords

  • group-based pride
  • group-based shame
  • collective pride
  • collective hubris
  • collective emotion
  • collective action

Cite this

@article{f5f813a1511d408a9866ce84624b14be,
title = "Collective Emotions in Celebratory, Competitive, and Conflictual Contexts:: Exploring the Dynamic Relations between Group-Based and Collective Pride and Shame",
abstract = "Pride and shame are typically viewed as diametrically opposed but dynamically related personal emotions that also occur in group-based and collective forms. Building upon seminal work by Cooley and Scheff to explain the generation and manifestation of these emotions in the imaginations and everyday realities of people’s social-relational individual and group lives, our analysis addresses contemporary developments in social and psychological science (Collins, Mackie & Smith, Reicher & Neville, Skey, Sullivan, von Scheve & Ismer, Wetherell), by highlighting patterns of complex, dynamic relations between occurrences of group-based pride, group-based shame, collective pride and collective shame in prototypical group contexts of celebration, competition and conflict. Our novel analysis includes underexplored group agency and performative details and we argue that mixtures of negative group pride and anger evident in collective hubris or contempt and some forms of aggression directed towards other groups are not necessarily produced by repression of collective shame.",
keywords = "group-based pride, group-based shame, collective pride, collective hubris, collective emotion, collective action",
author = "Sullivan, {Gavin Brent} and Christopher Day",
year = "2019",
month = "11",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1163/2208522X-02010057",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
pages = "202--222",
journal = "Emotions: History, culture, society",
issn = "2208-522X",
publisher = "Brill Nijhoff",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Collective Emotions in Celebratory, Competitive, and Conflictual Contexts:

T2 - Exploring the Dynamic Relations between Group-Based and Collective Pride and Shame

AU - Sullivan, Gavin Brent

AU - Day, Christopher

PY - 2019/11/15

Y1 - 2019/11/15

N2 - Pride and shame are typically viewed as diametrically opposed but dynamically related personal emotions that also occur in group-based and collective forms. Building upon seminal work by Cooley and Scheff to explain the generation and manifestation of these emotions in the imaginations and everyday realities of people’s social-relational individual and group lives, our analysis addresses contemporary developments in social and psychological science (Collins, Mackie & Smith, Reicher & Neville, Skey, Sullivan, von Scheve & Ismer, Wetherell), by highlighting patterns of complex, dynamic relations between occurrences of group-based pride, group-based shame, collective pride and collective shame in prototypical group contexts of celebration, competition and conflict. Our novel analysis includes underexplored group agency and performative details and we argue that mixtures of negative group pride and anger evident in collective hubris or contempt and some forms of aggression directed towards other groups are not necessarily produced by repression of collective shame.

AB - Pride and shame are typically viewed as diametrically opposed but dynamically related personal emotions that also occur in group-based and collective forms. Building upon seminal work by Cooley and Scheff to explain the generation and manifestation of these emotions in the imaginations and everyday realities of people’s social-relational individual and group lives, our analysis addresses contemporary developments in social and psychological science (Collins, Mackie & Smith, Reicher & Neville, Skey, Sullivan, von Scheve & Ismer, Wetherell), by highlighting patterns of complex, dynamic relations between occurrences of group-based pride, group-based shame, collective pride and collective shame in prototypical group contexts of celebration, competition and conflict. Our novel analysis includes underexplored group agency and performative details and we argue that mixtures of negative group pride and anger evident in collective hubris or contempt and some forms of aggression directed towards other groups are not necessarily produced by repression of collective shame.

KW - group-based pride

KW - group-based shame

KW - collective pride

KW - collective hubris

KW - collective emotion

KW - collective action

U2 - 10.1163/2208522X-02010057

DO - 10.1163/2208522X-02010057

M3 - Article

VL - 3

SP - 202

EP - 222

JO - Emotions: History, culture, society

JF - Emotions: History, culture, society

SN - 2208-522X

IS - 2

ER -