Child welfare interventions: reducing, reflecting or reinforcing social inequalities

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

    Abstract

    While there is a longstanding, if ambivalent, relationship between social work and families living in poverty, the question whether child welfare services reflect, reduce or reinforce social inequalities in family life and children's wellbeing remains little explored. Recent data from a 10% sample of children on child protection plans or being looked after in out-of-home care in England have shed new light on the extent and nature of the relationship between social deprivation at the neighbourhood level and social work interventions in family life. This paper reports key findings from that study, drawing on the analytical methods and concepts developed in the study of inequalities in health, such as the social gradient and the inverse care law. It provides evidence of very large socially structured inequalities in child welfare intervention rates and concludes that rates of intervention cannot be usefully compared between local administrative areas or nations without taking into account the impact of deprivation and ethnicity. However, the new information provided by this study also raises crucial questions, including whether higher or lower rates of intervention reflect greater safety for children, how we judge the effectiveness of national child welfare systems and the morality of the current (English) policy emphasis on adoption. The paper reports on the developing theory of child welfare inequalities and suggests a framework for international research.
    Original languageEnglish
    Publication statusPublished - 2015
    EventEuropean Conference for Social Work Research 2015 - Ljubljana, Slovenia
    Duration: 22 Apr 201524 Apr 2015

    Conference

    ConferenceEuropean Conference for Social Work Research 2015
    CountrySlovenia
    CityLjubljana
    Period22/04/1524/04/15

    Fingerprint

    social inequality
    child welfare
    social work
    social deprivation
    child protection
    home care
    deprivation
    morality
    ethnicity
    poverty
    Law
    health
    evidence

    Bibliographical note

    The full text of this item is not available from the repository.

    Keywords

    • child welfare
    • poverty
    • social work
    • looked-after children
    • child protection plans

    Cite this

    Bywaters, P. (2015). Child welfare interventions: reducing, reflecting or reinforcing social inequalities. Paper presented at European Conference for Social Work Research 2015, Ljubljana, Slovenia.

    Child welfare interventions: reducing, reflecting or reinforcing social inequalities. / Bywaters, Paul.

    2015. Paper presented at European Conference for Social Work Research 2015, Ljubljana, Slovenia.

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

    Bywaters, P 2015, 'Child welfare interventions: reducing, reflecting or reinforcing social inequalities' Paper presented at European Conference for Social Work Research 2015, Ljubljana, Slovenia, 22/04/15 - 24/04/15, .
    Bywaters P. Child welfare interventions: reducing, reflecting or reinforcing social inequalities. 2015. Paper presented at European Conference for Social Work Research 2015, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
    Bywaters, Paul. / Child welfare interventions: reducing, reflecting or reinforcing social inequalities. Paper presented at European Conference for Social Work Research 2015, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
    @conference{e22dc4010bdf40b1b89c7dbf4f22b1a6,
    title = "Child welfare interventions: reducing, reflecting or reinforcing social inequalities",
    abstract = "While there is a longstanding, if ambivalent, relationship between social work and families living in poverty, the question whether child welfare services reflect, reduce or reinforce social inequalities in family life and children's wellbeing remains little explored. Recent data from a 10{\%} sample of children on child protection plans or being looked after in out-of-home care in England have shed new light on the extent and nature of the relationship between social deprivation at the neighbourhood level and social work interventions in family life. This paper reports key findings from that study, drawing on the analytical methods and concepts developed in the study of inequalities in health, such as the social gradient and the inverse care law. It provides evidence of very large socially structured inequalities in child welfare intervention rates and concludes that rates of intervention cannot be usefully compared between local administrative areas or nations without taking into account the impact of deprivation and ethnicity. However, the new information provided by this study also raises crucial questions, including whether higher or lower rates of intervention reflect greater safety for children, how we judge the effectiveness of national child welfare systems and the morality of the current (English) policy emphasis on adoption. The paper reports on the developing theory of child welfare inequalities and suggests a framework for international research.",
    keywords = "child welfare, poverty, social work, looked-after children, child protection plans",
    author = "Paul Bywaters",
    note = "The full text of this item is not available from the repository.; European Conference for Social Work Research 2015 ; Conference date: 22-04-2015 Through 24-04-2015",
    year = "2015",
    language = "English",

    }

    TY - CONF

    T1 - Child welfare interventions: reducing, reflecting or reinforcing social inequalities

    AU - Bywaters, Paul

    N1 - The full text of this item is not available from the repository.

    PY - 2015

    Y1 - 2015

    N2 - While there is a longstanding, if ambivalent, relationship between social work and families living in poverty, the question whether child welfare services reflect, reduce or reinforce social inequalities in family life and children's wellbeing remains little explored. Recent data from a 10% sample of children on child protection plans or being looked after in out-of-home care in England have shed new light on the extent and nature of the relationship between social deprivation at the neighbourhood level and social work interventions in family life. This paper reports key findings from that study, drawing on the analytical methods and concepts developed in the study of inequalities in health, such as the social gradient and the inverse care law. It provides evidence of very large socially structured inequalities in child welfare intervention rates and concludes that rates of intervention cannot be usefully compared between local administrative areas or nations without taking into account the impact of deprivation and ethnicity. However, the new information provided by this study also raises crucial questions, including whether higher or lower rates of intervention reflect greater safety for children, how we judge the effectiveness of national child welfare systems and the morality of the current (English) policy emphasis on adoption. The paper reports on the developing theory of child welfare inequalities and suggests a framework for international research.

    AB - While there is a longstanding, if ambivalent, relationship between social work and families living in poverty, the question whether child welfare services reflect, reduce or reinforce social inequalities in family life and children's wellbeing remains little explored. Recent data from a 10% sample of children on child protection plans or being looked after in out-of-home care in England have shed new light on the extent and nature of the relationship between social deprivation at the neighbourhood level and social work interventions in family life. This paper reports key findings from that study, drawing on the analytical methods and concepts developed in the study of inequalities in health, such as the social gradient and the inverse care law. It provides evidence of very large socially structured inequalities in child welfare intervention rates and concludes that rates of intervention cannot be usefully compared between local administrative areas or nations without taking into account the impact of deprivation and ethnicity. However, the new information provided by this study also raises crucial questions, including whether higher or lower rates of intervention reflect greater safety for children, how we judge the effectiveness of national child welfare systems and the morality of the current (English) policy emphasis on adoption. The paper reports on the developing theory of child welfare inequalities and suggests a framework for international research.

    KW - child welfare

    KW - poverty

    KW - social work

    KW - looked-after children

    KW - child protection plans

    M3 - Paper

    ER -