Changing case Order to Optimise patterns of Performance in mammography Screening (CO-OPS): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

S. Taylor-Phillips, M. G. Wallis, H. Parsons, J. Dunn, N. Stallard, H. Campbell, S. Stellars, Ala Szczepura, S. Gates, A. Clarke

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    5 Citations (Scopus)
    6 Downloads (Pure)

    Abstract

    Background X-ray mammography remains the predominant test for screening for breast cancer, with the aim of reducing breast cancer mortality. In the English NHS Breast Screening Programme each woman’s mammograms are examined separately by two expert readers. The two readers read each batch in the same order and each indicates if there should be recall for further tests. This is a highly skilled, pressurised, repetitive and frequently intellectually unchallenging activity where readers examine one or more batches of 30–50 women’s mammograms in each session. A vigilance decrement or performance decrease over time has been observed in similar repetitive visual tasks such as radar operation. Methods/Design The CO-OPS study is a pragmatic, multi-centre, two-arm, double blind cluster randomised controlled trial of a computer software intervention designed to reduce the effects of a vigilance decrement in breast cancer screening. The unit of randomisation is the batch. Intervention batches will be examined in the opposite order by the two readers (one forwards, one backwards). Control batches will be read in the same order as one another, as is current standard practice. The hypothesis is that cancer detection rates will be higher in the intervention group because each readers’ peak performance will occur when examining different women’s mammograms. The trial will take place in 44 English breast screening centres for 1 year and 4 months. The primary outcome is cancer detection rate, which will be extracted from computer records after 1 year of the trial. The secondary outcomes include rate of disagreement between readers (a more statistically powerful surrogate for cancer detection rate), recall rate, positive predictive value, and interval cancer rate (cancers found between screening rounds which will be measured three years after the end of the trial). Discussion This is the first trial of an intervention to ameliorate a vigilance decrement in breast cancer screening. Trial registration ISRCTN46603370 (submitted: 24 October 2012, date of registration: 26 March 2013).
    Original languageEnglish
    Number of pages7
    JournalTrials
    Volume15
    Issue number17
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 10 Jan 2014

    Fingerprint

    Mammography
    Carbon Monoxide
    Randomized Controlled Trials
    Breast Neoplasms
    Neoplasms
    Early Detection of Cancer
    Breast
    Radar
    Random Allocation
    Arm
    Software
    Mortality

    Bibliographical note

    The full text is also available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1745-6215-15-17

    Keywords

    • Breast cancer
    • Fatigue
    • Mammography
    • Observer performance
    • Screening
    • Vigilance decrement

    Cite this

    Changing case Order to Optimise patterns of Performance in mammography Screening (CO-OPS): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. / Taylor-Phillips, S.; Wallis, M. G.; Parsons, H.; Dunn, J.; Stallard, N.; Campbell, H.; Stellars, S.; Szczepura, Ala; Gates, S.; Clarke, A.

    In: Trials, Vol. 15, No. 17, 10.01.2014.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Taylor-Phillips, S, Wallis, MG, Parsons, H, Dunn, J, Stallard, N, Campbell, H, Stellars, S, Szczepura, A, Gates, S & Clarke, A 2014, 'Changing case Order to Optimise patterns of Performance in mammography Screening (CO-OPS): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial' Trials, vol. 15, no. 17. https://doi.org/10.1186/1745-6215-15-17
    Taylor-Phillips, S. ; Wallis, M. G. ; Parsons, H. ; Dunn, J. ; Stallard, N. ; Campbell, H. ; Stellars, S. ; Szczepura, Ala ; Gates, S. ; Clarke, A. / Changing case Order to Optimise patterns of Performance in mammography Screening (CO-OPS): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. In: Trials. 2014 ; Vol. 15, No. 17.
    @article{be0d8f19c26d4e3ca244e53a27c62926,
    title = "Changing case Order to Optimise patterns of Performance in mammography Screening (CO-OPS): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial",
    abstract = "Background X-ray mammography remains the predominant test for screening for breast cancer, with the aim of reducing breast cancer mortality. In the English NHS Breast Screening Programme each woman’s mammograms are examined separately by two expert readers. The two readers read each batch in the same order and each indicates if there should be recall for further tests. This is a highly skilled, pressurised, repetitive and frequently intellectually unchallenging activity where readers examine one or more batches of 30–50 women’s mammograms in each session. A vigilance decrement or performance decrease over time has been observed in similar repetitive visual tasks such as radar operation. Methods/Design The CO-OPS study is a pragmatic, multi-centre, two-arm, double blind cluster randomised controlled trial of a computer software intervention designed to reduce the effects of a vigilance decrement in breast cancer screening. The unit of randomisation is the batch. Intervention batches will be examined in the opposite order by the two readers (one forwards, one backwards). Control batches will be read in the same order as one another, as is current standard practice. The hypothesis is that cancer detection rates will be higher in the intervention group because each readers’ peak performance will occur when examining different women’s mammograms. The trial will take place in 44 English breast screening centres for 1 year and 4 months. The primary outcome is cancer detection rate, which will be extracted from computer records after 1 year of the trial. The secondary outcomes include rate of disagreement between readers (a more statistically powerful surrogate for cancer detection rate), recall rate, positive predictive value, and interval cancer rate (cancers found between screening rounds which will be measured three years after the end of the trial). Discussion This is the first trial of an intervention to ameliorate a vigilance decrement in breast cancer screening. Trial registration ISRCTN46603370 (submitted: 24 October 2012, date of registration: 26 March 2013).",
    keywords = "Breast cancer, Fatigue, Mammography, Observer performance, Screening, Vigilance decrement",
    author = "S. Taylor-Phillips and Wallis, {M. G.} and H. Parsons and J. Dunn and N. Stallard and H. Campbell and S. Stellars and Ala Szczepura and S. Gates and A. Clarke",
    note = "The full text is also available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1745-6215-15-17",
    year = "2014",
    month = "1",
    day = "10",
    doi = "10.1186/1745-6215-15-17",
    language = "English",
    volume = "15",
    journal = "Trials",
    issn = "1745-6215",
    publisher = "Springer Verlag",
    number = "17",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Changing case Order to Optimise patterns of Performance in mammography Screening (CO-OPS): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

    AU - Taylor-Phillips, S.

    AU - Wallis, M. G.

    AU - Parsons, H.

    AU - Dunn, J.

    AU - Stallard, N.

    AU - Campbell, H.

    AU - Stellars, S.

    AU - Szczepura, Ala

    AU - Gates, S.

    AU - Clarke, A.

    N1 - The full text is also available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1745-6215-15-17

    PY - 2014/1/10

    Y1 - 2014/1/10

    N2 - Background X-ray mammography remains the predominant test for screening for breast cancer, with the aim of reducing breast cancer mortality. In the English NHS Breast Screening Programme each woman’s mammograms are examined separately by two expert readers. The two readers read each batch in the same order and each indicates if there should be recall for further tests. This is a highly skilled, pressurised, repetitive and frequently intellectually unchallenging activity where readers examine one or more batches of 30–50 women’s mammograms in each session. A vigilance decrement or performance decrease over time has been observed in similar repetitive visual tasks such as radar operation. Methods/Design The CO-OPS study is a pragmatic, multi-centre, two-arm, double blind cluster randomised controlled trial of a computer software intervention designed to reduce the effects of a vigilance decrement in breast cancer screening. The unit of randomisation is the batch. Intervention batches will be examined in the opposite order by the two readers (one forwards, one backwards). Control batches will be read in the same order as one another, as is current standard practice. The hypothesis is that cancer detection rates will be higher in the intervention group because each readers’ peak performance will occur when examining different women’s mammograms. The trial will take place in 44 English breast screening centres for 1 year and 4 months. The primary outcome is cancer detection rate, which will be extracted from computer records after 1 year of the trial. The secondary outcomes include rate of disagreement between readers (a more statistically powerful surrogate for cancer detection rate), recall rate, positive predictive value, and interval cancer rate (cancers found between screening rounds which will be measured three years after the end of the trial). Discussion This is the first trial of an intervention to ameliorate a vigilance decrement in breast cancer screening. Trial registration ISRCTN46603370 (submitted: 24 October 2012, date of registration: 26 March 2013).

    AB - Background X-ray mammography remains the predominant test for screening for breast cancer, with the aim of reducing breast cancer mortality. In the English NHS Breast Screening Programme each woman’s mammograms are examined separately by two expert readers. The two readers read each batch in the same order and each indicates if there should be recall for further tests. This is a highly skilled, pressurised, repetitive and frequently intellectually unchallenging activity where readers examine one or more batches of 30–50 women’s mammograms in each session. A vigilance decrement or performance decrease over time has been observed in similar repetitive visual tasks such as radar operation. Methods/Design The CO-OPS study is a pragmatic, multi-centre, two-arm, double blind cluster randomised controlled trial of a computer software intervention designed to reduce the effects of a vigilance decrement in breast cancer screening. The unit of randomisation is the batch. Intervention batches will be examined in the opposite order by the two readers (one forwards, one backwards). Control batches will be read in the same order as one another, as is current standard practice. The hypothesis is that cancer detection rates will be higher in the intervention group because each readers’ peak performance will occur when examining different women’s mammograms. The trial will take place in 44 English breast screening centres for 1 year and 4 months. The primary outcome is cancer detection rate, which will be extracted from computer records after 1 year of the trial. The secondary outcomes include rate of disagreement between readers (a more statistically powerful surrogate for cancer detection rate), recall rate, positive predictive value, and interval cancer rate (cancers found between screening rounds which will be measured three years after the end of the trial). Discussion This is the first trial of an intervention to ameliorate a vigilance decrement in breast cancer screening. Trial registration ISRCTN46603370 (submitted: 24 October 2012, date of registration: 26 March 2013).

    KW - Breast cancer

    KW - Fatigue

    KW - Mammography

    KW - Observer performance

    KW - Screening

    KW - Vigilance decrement

    U2 - 10.1186/1745-6215-15-17

    DO - 10.1186/1745-6215-15-17

    M3 - Article

    VL - 15

    JO - Trials

    JF - Trials

    SN - 1745-6215

    IS - 17

    ER -