Absence of a market in the Dutch balancing mechanism: European rules versus specific investments

Eva Niesten, Albert Jolink

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)
46 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The European directives for the electricity industry prescribe the creation of a market for balancing electricity supply and demand. In this paper, we demonstrate that a market for balancing has not emerged in the Dutch electricity industry, and that, instead, the balancing transactions are governed by regulated, long-term contracts and a bidding mechanism. We explain the absence of a balancing market by using the framework of transaction cost economics, in which the efficiency of a market decreases with increasing investments in specific assets. The results of a questionnaire among the energy firms that supply balancing power in the Dutch setting show that these firms have invested in specific physical, temporal and dedicated balancing assets. The need for these specific investments to balance supply and demand does not only explain the absence of a market, but also the lack of participation by small firms in the balancing mechanism. We recommend several policies, such as stimulating technological developments for the storage of electricity and demand side management, which reduce these specific investments in balancing assets, and thereby stimulate the creation of a market and the participation of small firms.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)71-90
Number of pages20
JournalEuropean Journal of Law and Economics
Volume38
Issue number1
Early online date26 Jul 2013
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 26 Aug 2014

Fingerprint

market
electricity
firm
assets
demand
term contract
electricity supply
participation
Specific investments
industry
transaction costs
technical development
transaction
supply
energy
efficiency
questionnaire
lack
management
economics

Keywords

  • Balancing mechanism
  • Specific investments
  • Electricity market
  • European rules
  • Transaction cost economics
  • D23
  • K23
  • L22
  • L94
  • Q48

Cite this

Absence of a market in the Dutch balancing mechanism : European rules versus specific investments. / Niesten, Eva; Jolink, Albert.

In: European Journal of Law and Economics, Vol. 38, No. 1, 26.08.2014, p. 71-90.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{a9192694b5f24c6181edbc214d8e890e,
title = "Absence of a market in the Dutch balancing mechanism: European rules versus specific investments",
abstract = "The European directives for the electricity industry prescribe the creation of a market for balancing electricity supply and demand. In this paper, we demonstrate that a market for balancing has not emerged in the Dutch electricity industry, and that, instead, the balancing transactions are governed by regulated, long-term contracts and a bidding mechanism. We explain the absence of a balancing market by using the framework of transaction cost economics, in which the efficiency of a market decreases with increasing investments in specific assets. The results of a questionnaire among the energy firms that supply balancing power in the Dutch setting show that these firms have invested in specific physical, temporal and dedicated balancing assets. The need for these specific investments to balance supply and demand does not only explain the absence of a market, but also the lack of participation by small firms in the balancing mechanism. We recommend several policies, such as stimulating technological developments for the storage of electricity and demand side management, which reduce these specific investments in balancing assets, and thereby stimulate the creation of a market and the participation of small firms.",
keywords = "Balancing mechanism, Specific investments, Electricity market, European rules, Transaction cost economics, D23, K23, L22, L94, Q48",
author = "Eva Niesten and Albert Jolink",
year = "2014",
month = "8",
day = "26",
doi = "10.1007/s10657-013-9411-2",
language = "English",
volume = "38",
pages = "71--90",
journal = "European Journal of Law and Economics",
issn = "0929-1261",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Absence of a market in the Dutch balancing mechanism

T2 - European rules versus specific investments

AU - Niesten, Eva

AU - Jolink, Albert

PY - 2014/8/26

Y1 - 2014/8/26

N2 - The European directives for the electricity industry prescribe the creation of a market for balancing electricity supply and demand. In this paper, we demonstrate that a market for balancing has not emerged in the Dutch electricity industry, and that, instead, the balancing transactions are governed by regulated, long-term contracts and a bidding mechanism. We explain the absence of a balancing market by using the framework of transaction cost economics, in which the efficiency of a market decreases with increasing investments in specific assets. The results of a questionnaire among the energy firms that supply balancing power in the Dutch setting show that these firms have invested in specific physical, temporal and dedicated balancing assets. The need for these specific investments to balance supply and demand does not only explain the absence of a market, but also the lack of participation by small firms in the balancing mechanism. We recommend several policies, such as stimulating technological developments for the storage of electricity and demand side management, which reduce these specific investments in balancing assets, and thereby stimulate the creation of a market and the participation of small firms.

AB - The European directives for the electricity industry prescribe the creation of a market for balancing electricity supply and demand. In this paper, we demonstrate that a market for balancing has not emerged in the Dutch electricity industry, and that, instead, the balancing transactions are governed by regulated, long-term contracts and a bidding mechanism. We explain the absence of a balancing market by using the framework of transaction cost economics, in which the efficiency of a market decreases with increasing investments in specific assets. The results of a questionnaire among the energy firms that supply balancing power in the Dutch setting show that these firms have invested in specific physical, temporal and dedicated balancing assets. The need for these specific investments to balance supply and demand does not only explain the absence of a market, but also the lack of participation by small firms in the balancing mechanism. We recommend several policies, such as stimulating technological developments for the storage of electricity and demand side management, which reduce these specific investments in balancing assets, and thereby stimulate the creation of a market and the participation of small firms.

KW - Balancing mechanism

KW - Specific investments

KW - Electricity market

KW - European rules

KW - Transaction cost economics

KW - D23

KW - K23

KW - L22

KW - L94

KW - Q48

U2 - 10.1007/s10657-013-9411-2

DO - 10.1007/s10657-013-9411-2

M3 - Article

VL - 38

SP - 71

EP - 90

JO - European Journal of Law and Economics

JF - European Journal of Law and Economics

SN - 0929-1261

IS - 1

ER -